The Adoption Industry{secti
WHAT
Industry? | BIG BUSINESS: $1.4 Billion |
Adoption Affects Millions | CONSUMER
DEMAND | The
Industry Admits COERCION |
Today's
"Modus Operandi"
WHAT
Industry?
Like
any other industry, adoption is fueled by consumer
demand. In this case, the demand of infertile couples to
obtain other women's children, and who are often willing to pay
from $25,000 to $50,000 for that child.
BIG
BUSINESS:
Adoption Services Valued At $1.4 Billion
Report
by Nancy Ashe Copyright © 2001 About.com, Inc.
"An
industry analysis of Fertility Clinics and Adoption Services
by Marketdata Enterprises of Tampa, FL, has placed a $1.4
billion value on adoption services in the US, with a projected
annual growth rate of 11.5% to 2004. According to a report
from PR Newswire, this is the only analysis of this business
sector ever undertaken.
Some
details:
-
In 1999, there were 138,000 US adoptions;
-
There are 4,500 adoption services providers in the US,
which include 2,000 public agencies, 2,000 private agencies,
and 500 adoption attorneys;
-
The number of attorneys involved in adoption has doubled
over the past 10 years;
-
Gross income for small agencies can come to $400,000 per
year, and $10+ million for large agencies.
-
Much of the present and future growth is attributable
to the rise in international adoptions.
Marketdata's
analysis places adoption costs between $15,000 - $30,000,
and describes adoption as 'complex, and stories of unscrupulous
operators abound in this loosely regulated field.' "
From "About.Com:
About Adoption"
Reprinted with Permission of Author
|
Adoption Affects Millions
There
are approximately 6 million adoptees in the United States. We can
extrapolate that there are usually 4 of parents involved in each
adoption (two natural parents and two dopters). This increases the
number to 24 million people involved in Adoption. Add siblings,
stepparents, facilitators, grandparents, aunts, uncles, and it is
not illogical to conclude that there are over 100 million people
in the United States involved in Adoption.
There
are costs involved in the original adoption - usually fees paid
by adopters to a "third party" who acts as a broker. Examples
of some fees are:
-
Religious
Agencies: A few hundred dollars to $10,000.00 or more
-
Non-denominational
Private Agencies: $10,000 to $20,000
-
Independent
[Private] Adoption: A few thousand dollars to $50,000 but
may be higher if there are extremely high medical bills.
-
Public
Agencies: None to minimal. There may be attorney fees to finalize
the adoption
-
International
Adoption: $5,000 -$20,000 to the agency plus transportation
and lodging fees.
This
is why there are entrepreneurs who make their livelihood convincing
young parents to relinquish their babies - it is a profitable business.
These "baby brokers" include: adoption
lawyers
maternity homes (often operated by charities and churches) "facilitators"
government
social workers commercial
and "non-profit" agencies 
Consumer Demand
Like
all industries, the adoption industry is driven by consumer demand.
This demand was recognized as far back as 1953:
"... the tendency
growing out of the demand for babies is to regard unmarried
mothers as breeding machines...(by people intent) upon securing
babies for quick adoptions." - Leontine Young, "Is
Money Our Trouble?" (paper presented at the National Conference
of Social Workers, Cleveland, 1953) {quote courtesy of Karen
WB}
". . . babies
born out of wedlock [are] no longer considered a social problem
. . . white, physically healthy babies are considered by many
to be a social boon . . . " (i.e. a valuable commodity..).
- Social Work and Social Problems (1964), National Association
of Social Workers. {quote courtesy of Karen
WB}
" Because there
are many more married couples wanting to adopt newborn white
babies than there are babies, it may almost be said that they,
rather than out of wedlock babies, are a social problem. (Sometimes
social workers in adoption agencies have facetiously suggested
setting up social provisions for more 'baby breeding.')"
- Social Work and Social Problems (1964), National Association
of Social Workers. {quote courtesy of Karen
WB}
The
Industry Admits Coercion:
When
unmarried motherhood was considered shameful to the family, it was
easy to convince parents to ship their unwed daughter to maternity
homes (assuming that marriage had been ruled out) and adoption lawyers:
"Parents
embraced the idea of maternity homes partly because in the postwar
decades, parents themselves needed protection as much as their
erring daughters... If the girl disappeared, the problem disappeared
with her." - Rickie Solinger, "Wake
Up Little Suzie."
Pressure
from society, churches, parents, maternity homes, hospitals etc.
- plus the virtual non-existance of welfare for young single mothers
- virtually guaranteed that a young woman raised to respect authority
would surrender her baby. As well, social workers were convinced
that unwed equalled unfit, that that they were doing their moral
duty in convincing (forcing/coercing) young women to surrender:
"When she renounces her child for its own good, the unwed
mother has learned a lot She has learned an important human
value. She has learned to pay the price for her misdemeanor.
and this alone, if punishment is needed, is punishment enough.
-- Dr. Marion Hilliard. Toronto Telegram (November 22,
1956)
"
The fact that social work professional attitudes tend to favor
the relinquishment of the baby, as the literature shows, should
be faced more clearly. Perhaps if it were recognized, workers
would be in less conflict and would therefore feel less guilty
about their "failures" (the kept cases)." - Social
worker Barbara Hansen Costigan, in her dissertation, "The
Unmarried Mother--Her Decision Regarding Adoption" (1964)
{quote
courtesy of Karen
WB}
"
The caseworker must then be decisive, firm and unswerving in
her pursuit of a healthy solution for the girl's problem. The
"I'm going to help you by standing by while you work it
through" approach will not do. What is expected from the
worker is precisely what the child expected but did not get
from her parents--a decisive "No!" .... An ambivalent
mother, interfering with her daughter's ability ... to surrender
her child, must be dealt with as though she (the girl's mother)
were a child herself." - Marcel Heiman, M.D. in "Out-Of-Wedlock
Pregnancy In Adolescence," Casework Papers 1960. {quote
courtesy of Karen
WB}
Governments
had (and still do have) their own incentive for encouraging the
adoption industry. Every baby surrendered by an unemployed unsupported
single mother means one less welfare recipient. An example: if
a single parent is eligible for welfare until their child was 7
years old, a government saves $35,000 (7 x $5,000 annually) in welfare
payments each time its social workers obtain a surrender. Federal
governments also encourage adoption by providing cash bonuses to
states for every adoption completed.
"To
the Province generally the great advantage and economy of the
Adoption Act can be realized when it is stated that many
of the children before their adoption were costing five and
six dollars a week for maintenance." - 35th Report of
the Superintendent of Neglected and Dependent Children (Ontario,
1928)
Today's
Modus Operandi
As
divorce rates rose in the 70's and 80's, single parenthood lost
its stigma, women no longer experienced the same societal/family
pressure to surrender, and the number of babies surrendered in the
U.S. and Canada began falling. Consumer demand has, if anything,
risen dramatically, as women who have postponed children for careers
are now finding themselves infertile (see the April 15, 2002 Time
magazine article "Making
Time for a Baby"). According to Adoptive Families
magazine, "For every healthy newborn available, there are now
almost forty potential parents searching." ("Love
for Sale," Adoptive Families).
With
money to be made from desperate "Family Builders," the
industry has had to come up with new ways of obtaining its commodities.
They have done this through modern marketing and advertising tactics.
- Adopters
have now formed "consumer groups." Pressure from these
consumer groups on government has led to laws changing to vastly
decrease the time period in which a woman can revoke her surrender
or consent to adoption.
- Adoption
lawyers are promoting the legal idea that, if a child is
placed in an adoptive home even before the adoption in consented
to, the adopters have the right to retain that child against
any challenge from the natural parents (see the "Children's
Rights" page by the American
Academy of Adoption Attorneys).
- The
Internet has increasing numbers of websites set up to encourage
women to "place" their children. Agencies and lawyers
fund these websites by purchasing advertising space on them.
| "Adoption
was created to provide homes for orphans. These by definition
are children without parents. Car crashes, war, natural disasters.
It was never created to provide children to 'poor infertile
couples'. When did the wires get crossed? I guess when someone
started making money. Children are not a commodity!!!! Get
a puppy."
-
An adoptee
"Follow
the money" -
Deep Throat
|
ontitle}
|